• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Primary Cementing
  • Remedial Cementing
  • Plug Cementing
  • Job Execution
  • Post-job results interpretation
  • Equipment
  • Laboratory
  • Mission
  • About
  • Contact and Questions?
  • My Cementing Challenges

Better Well Cementing for ALL

The Leading Online Support Hub for Better Oil Well Cementing.

Highly deviated or Horizontal well section abandonment?

January 31, 2019 By Lenin Diaz 6 Comments

Highly deviated or Horizontal well section abandonment?

I have to be honest, it is only recently that I had the opportunity to place frequent cement plugs in such conditions and purpose. 

Yes, I did those only occasionally before …

However, “Frequency” is important, and beside what everybody knows (so-called best practices) Frequency is how the significance of all the variables can be really appreciated.

You might ask yourself sometime; Why if I have implemented all the best practices in the book, still the cement plug wasn’t successful? 

Well, eventually, anybody can normally get it … after all, probing (trial and error) is a way of learning, yet always costly and not necessarily long lasting.

Let’s go back to the creed …

Do your best initial assessment of the circumstances … (a) Understand your objectives, the well, the challenges and hole conditions;

build your best model and be ready to adjust … (b) Engineer your job;

deploy as planned … (c) Controlled, supervised execution and the most important;

understand the outcome … (d) Take the learnings through post-job analysis, sustain or change.

This is particularly true for cement plugs in Highly deviated or Horizontal sections. But what is it Highly deviated? A wellbore at an angle from vertical that exceeds 80 degrees. Here what looms us:

  • Plug cementing in Highly deviated and Horizontal wells is increasingly challenging, particularly as the reach and depth increase;
  • Hole cleaning (static cuttings) and “proper” before-job conditions;
  • Mud displacement becomes more challenging as inclination and horizontal section length increase (longer sections result in higher ECD limiting displacement rate); and
  • Density hierarchy does not play a significant role.

Now, let’s start from the beginning … Can We place a cement plug using the Balanced Plug Technique across Highly deviated or Horizontal well section?

Not really, because there is very little to no balancing with Gravity pulling perpendicularly (or close to) and making anything heavier than the mud to slump low side, unless the diference in fluid properties comes to an equilibrium at some time.

Remember: the force to balance the cement plug is the hydrostatic differential pressure between the inside of the placement pipe and the annulus, and this force needs to overcome the resistance to flow given by the mud and the cement slurry.

Calculate here the length of the slump

NOTE: Change fluid properties if SLUMP is negative. It means the cement plug slurry would continue to flow down and/or up the hole.

NOTE: Slump lenght at top and bottom are not necesarrily the same. However, considered equal here as a simplification.

The cement slurry will slump underneath the mud both below and above the plug. The cement volume must be enough so that there is sufficient section of hole covered with cement. The minimum cement volume being approximately equal to two times the volume slumped plus your desired cement plug length (volume). In other words:

( Hole Diameter )^2 * ( 0.000054 * Slump Length + Desired Plug Length / 1029.4 ) [bbl]

NOTE: Slump and Plug lenght in feet; Hole Diameter in inches

Your “cementing engineer” mind, already in motion, now knows what to do to mitigate the slump: a) make cement slurry flow more difficult; and b) increase cement volume. In other words, play with the cement slurry yield point and/or cement excess.

Wait a minute, but We still need to POOH the pipe, correct? … 

Yes! Pull the pipe out of the cement and in the same direction it is slumping! … That doesn’t sound too good, does it?

The problem: how can I remove and clean/wipe my pipe minimizing disturbance of the cement in place?

You have 3 choices (from more to less beneficial):

  1. Leave the pipe (tail pipe) in place. Disposable pipe (aluminum or fiber glass sacrificial pipe) alone or with disconnecting tool;
  2. Pump and Pull method. Mimicking a cement plug with CT, Pumping the hole capacity in a joint length at the same time the joint is pulled out of the hole; and
  3. Plug placement tool or similar, however the higher the Tool OD and hole dimeter ratio the more swabbing.

And a fourth … yes! Another “possible” alternative:

Pump the job like a conventional cement plug. If placed on-bottom and the ratio between hole diameter and plug length is less than 0.04, but more than 0.02, as a reference. These are empirical numbers, cementing engineers are called to use proper judgement here depending on specific well conditions.

In any case consider all the precautions for cement plugs, the need for cement excess and select the correct tail pipe, e.g., PIPE OD = 0.49 * HOLE DIAMETER + 0.17 [in] and round to the closes existing OD.

Other things to consider:

  • A small stinger is beneficial but increases the resistance to move out the cement behind and inside the pipe, for the Pump-and-Pull and the conventional method;
  • rotation could be favorable, depending on hole geometry and stinger OD, while circulating and cleaning hole and whilst placing the cement slurry;
  • for holes in excess of 85 degrees the recommended cement slurry yield point is around 25 to 35 lb./100 ft^2;
  • under-displacement has to be considered on case-by-case basis, e.g., cement slurry bottom hole behavior (as seen in the TT chart, including static time), use of tapered pipe, implementation of the Pump-and-pull or conventional method;
  • the Pump-and-pull method assumes the mud is not balancing itself when pulling out of the cement plug, therefore it needs to be pumped down for every stand pulled out to allow the cement slurry out of the stinger. This methodology allows placement of longer cement plugs, as long as: the end of the stinger is always inside cement (do not consider the slump), there is cement inside the stinger (under-displacement is contemplated) and the hole volume in a joint length is pumped out at the same time the joint is pulled out of the hole. It is important to mention that the Pump-and-pull method requires proper job planning and supervised execution.

Some more …

  • It is fundamental to have the hole properly cleaned prior the job;
  • Consider cement slurry contamination to run the UCA to estimate the WOC before tagging or testing. In some cases, the use of mechanical separators (wiper balls) could be necessary;
  • CORRECT Temperature selection, meaning a well-estimated BHST and even better assumed BHCT;
  • Thickening time shall be Job time with safety margin, as per the company policy. In some cases, perform the Thickening time test with go-no go;
  • Pull out of the hole the working string slowly;
  • Batch mix the slurry. The Pump-and-pull method might allow pumping-on-the-fly for larger cement slurry volume (Warning, good/expert cementing engineering is required); and
  • a diverter tool is not as important as for vertical wells.

I really appreciate your comments and feedback

Cheers

L. Diaz

Related posts:

  1. Some guidelines for Cement Plugs
  2. Liner Cementing Challenges and Solutions
  3. Drill deeper or just plug it off?
  4. Balance to succeed: Cement Plugs in losses situation

Filed Under: General, Plug Cementing, Remedial Cementing Tagged With: Horizontal, plug, Pump-and-pull

Article Posted By:

Lenin Diaz is an oil industry specialist with 24 years of technical and operational expertise in fluids, cementing, water control and shut-off. A distinguished track record spanning BP, Schlumberger, and NAPESCO. Lenin lives in Tenerife, Spain and is the creator of this website. Read More…

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Paul Howlett says

    February 2, 2019 at 9:11 pm

    Have you actually used Aluminium Tubing as a disposinle stinger?

    Reply
    • Lenin Diaz says

      February 5, 2019 at 12:43 pm

      Hi Paul, glad to see your comment. Personally, I haven’t used Aluminum tubing as tail pipe or stinger to leave it inside the cement. Compared with fiberglass, aluminum appears as the best alternative for deeper open hole applications. The use of either of these pipes can be as a contingency, in case of aggressive and quick setting stuff like cement for severe lost circulation, long cement plugs, etc., or planned (very interesting) to increase success rate of cement plugs (no POOH).

      Please if you (or anybody) have an actual case, please mentioned here in the discussion

      Cheers
      L. Diaz

      Reply
      • Jeff Long says

        February 5, 2019 at 6:58 pm

        Hi Lenin, very good post. Another placement method to consider is a pipe release tool. This allows you to create the sacrificial stinger with whatever pipe you like. A dart is dropped behind the cement and a tool releases the pipe. These have been used extensively in deepwater with good success.

        Reply
        • Lenin Diaz says

          February 6, 2019 at 3:16 pm

          Thanks a lot Jeff, for sharing your experience. Definitely another method to consider

          Reply
  2. Steve Hauxwell says

    March 29, 2019 at 2:37 pm

    Hi Lenin,
    This is a great article, and tackles a subject that is always the topic of heated discussions. In general, Drilling Engineers are very aware of poor success rates associated with setting plugs in highly-deviated, or horizontal hole sections. If there is a way to avoid setting plugs, then it is often found. Common mitigations often include setting deeper casing shoes from the previous hole section, thereby offering the opportunity to set mechanical plugs and the perform cased hole side-tracks.
    Dealing with permanent hole abandonments, there is often no alternative solution, with cement being the only proven method for permanent isolation. Both Paul and Jeff often sound alternatives with the solution being to leave the cement stinger in-situ. In operations where this technology is perhaps not immediately available (e.g. geological sidetracks where waiting on tools carries an unacceptably high waiting time cost exposure), your suggested methods of ensuring the plug stays balanced are surely very welcome.

    Reply
    • Lenin Diaz says

      March 30, 2019 at 4:58 am

      Thanks, Steve, it is good to hear from you again. Setting cement plugs is not one of my favorites operations, honestly, but it is one of my favorites jobs to engineer. No contradiction in this last statement. Let me explain, operationally setting cement plugs has many variables and you can see how the success rate varies from one location to another. Failed Jobs occasionally included by force in the pages of the “book of oilfield mysteries”. This is because when used as a mean to resume drilling or well operations, there is always a rush to get it done, sometimes underestimating the importance of time in cementing operations: time for proper lab testing a slurry that was probably not foreseen, time for logistics, time for the cement to set and ultimately the Non-productive time if it fails.
      So, why it is one of my favorites jobs to engineer? Because of the TOC prediction. A task that requires proper engineering acknowledging all the variables that play a role.
      The last thing you want to hear is that the rig is washing down through soft cement … should they wash down or wait more time? Not always easy to answer, but in my experience wait some extra time has been best choice more than 75% of the time, if I have to put a number.

      Thanks for your comment
      Cheers
      L. Diaz

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Following the loss of my job in 2016 after a 20 year long career at that time, I started to post in LinkedIn, a series of 'Cementing Challenges' to keep ours minds 'active' around our beloved topic of well Cementing. This interaction with our community and their reaction to the 'challenges' was a fruitful learning experience, but to be honest it wasn’t enough to fill the space this downturn has left by keeping me away from the 'action'. This inspired me to go further not abandoning my passion in Cementing, but to dedicate a web site to well cementing and helping people.

How I survived the 2016 Downturn and the current difficult times?

Find the content you need

Archives

24 Page Free Primary Cementing Guide

Click this image to take a look. It is comprehensive and easy to follow too!

In 2016, I launched Better Cementing for All. Now, I want to keep it alive.

For more than 24 years, I have worked in oil well cementing, offering my services to some of the largest oil corporations in the world and committing myself to excellence. I have mastered my role, and in doing so, I have accrued a skill set that is extremely valuable to my fellow professionals. Eager to do whatever I can to help them, I have owned and operated Better Cementing for All since 2016.
Let me tell you what Better Cementing for All does and what it means. A resource for all oil industry professionals and for cementers both established and prospective, this is a non-profit resource that I established in order to do nothing but serve and make an impact on people who are looking to build careers for themselves in cementing.
From primary cementing to remedial cementing to plug cementing to post-job results, I do it all, and I am comfortable answering in-depth questions about each and every one of these topics. I also offer tools and tips for jobseekers, general self-development advice, and guidance for equipment choices. TO put it simply, this is the go-to spot for anyone who wants to know anything about oil well cementing.
The problem, however, is that covid-19 has made the structure of the website seem untenable. I am trying to juggle the work that I do and my non-profit initiatives and finding it all unhealthy and unsustainable. I want to keep Better Cementing for All up and running, but to do that, I need your help.


My NEW introductory VIDEO

Recent Posts

Forensic Cementing

Forensic is a term associated with "crimes." Properly, it is the use of science to investigate a … [Read More...] about Forensic Cementing

Cement Slurry design Basics

Additive TypePurposeConsiderationsExtenders IWater, Bentonite (clays), pozzolans, amorphous silica, … [Read More...] about Cement Slurry design Basics

well cementing pre-job cement challenge question

Remedial Cementing with Coiled Tubing (animation)

Far from being an animation expert, in my training courses, I always wanted to show my students a … [Read More...] about Remedial Cementing with Coiled Tubing (animation)

Illustration: cement substitutes to provide zonal isolation

Webinar series (III). P&A (Spanish)

I am very happy to present here a webinar series on well cementing for my Spanish-speaking readers. … [Read More...] about Webinar series (III). P&A (Spanish)

Webinar series (II). Quality Assurance in Cementing Operations (Spanish)

I am very happy to present here a webinar series on well cementing for my Spanish-speaking readers. … [Read More...] about Webinar series (II). Quality Assurance in Cementing Operations (Spanish)

Webinar series (I). Log interpretation (Spanish)

I am very happy to present here a webinar series on well cementing for my Spanish-speaking readers. … [Read More...] about Webinar series (I). Log interpretation (Spanish)

Need urgent help?

WhatsApp me at this number: +34 657 07 01 78

Footer

Recent activity

Visit our latest posts and help others by adding a comment.

Make your contribution and help keep Better Cementing for All alive!

Now more than ever, we are facing a loss of expertise in our industry, and Better Cementing for All is a unifying force, featuring interactions among industry professionals, knowledge sharing through posts, and other valuable pieces of content that we need to preserve.

Recent Comments

  • Lenin Diaz on Cementing Equipment
  • Lenin Diaz on Workover Cementing Techniques. (2) Squeeze Cementing
  • Ember Duran on Workover Cementing Techniques. (2) Squeeze Cementing
  • Merit on Cementing Equipment
  • Lenin Diaz on Cement Slurry design Basics
  • Lenin Diaz on Forensic Cementing
  • Lenin Diaz on Forensic Cementing

Recent Posts

  • Forensic Cementing
  • Cement Slurry design Basics
  • Remedial Cementing with Coiled Tubing (animation)
  • Webinar series (III). P&A (Spanish)
  • Webinar series (II). Quality Assurance in Cementing Operations (Spanish)
  • Webinar series (I). Log interpretation (Spanish)
  • Is a base necessary for your Cement Plug? – Part 2
  • A Cement Plug… just get it right the first time! – Part 1
  • Excellent cement job, but with terrible results … how is this possible?

Submit your email

&middot Better Well Cementing For All is owned by L. Diaz © 2021 &middot TOS & Privacy Policy &middot Web Design &middot