• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Primary Cementing
  • Remedial Cementing
  • Plug Cementing
  • Job Execution
  • Post-job results interpretation
  • Equipment
  • Laboratory
  • Mission
  • About
  • Contact and Questions?
  • My Cementing Challenges

Better Well Cementing for ALL

The Leading Online Support Hub for Better Oil Well Cementing.

A Cement Plug… just get it right the first time! – Part 1

September 14, 2020 By Lenin Diaz 6 Comments

A Cement Plug… just get it right the first time! – Part 1

In the past, I have written extensively about plug cementing, perhaps more than any other topic on this website, and the reason is simple: cement plugs are challenging. In my case, my eyes started to open back in Mexico while attempting deep sidetrack cement plugs.

Technical diagram for plug cementing

An SPE resulted from that trauma in Mexico after we finally got it under control, bringing success rates up to 100%, almost inconceivable before our time. After this experience, each time in every part of the world, in any operating environment and independently of the well’s purpose, objective, or condition, I have taken cement plugs very seriously, more than any other job type. And simply because I want to do just one! Get it right the first time.

A summary of cement plugs guidelines for drilling and workover is already available on this website, as applicable to the main reason for failure:

  1. Cement slurry contamination during placement, inside the tubing or DP, at the front and/or rear interfaces. Mentioned in Actions to prevent contamination and liner cementing, as applicable to in-pipe interface mixing.
liner cementing technical diagram
  1. Over-displacement.
  1. Pulling out of the hole too fast, swabbing while POOH or unknown hole size (OH).
  1. Unstable cement plug base.
    • Place a hard base, like a bridge plug.
    • Cement density > pre-flush / spacer density > control fluid
    • Viscous pill as a base (require proper design)
    • For low density brines, the pre-flush can be water.

Assuming the slurry is designed correctly using the right reference temperature, overall, the main issue is contamination.

Slurry contamination in plug cementing

That is why longer WOC and careful tagging/circulation are acceptable mitigations, however with an associated cost: extra time, but always better than repeating the job.

NOTE: This post only covers cement plugs positively affected by gravity. See https://better-cementing-for-all.org/highly-deviated-and-horizontal-well-section-abandonment for horizontal cement plugs.

Horizontal Cement Plug. Gravity is acting perpendicularly

In general, cement plugs job complexity is related to hole size, depth, and wellbore fluid. For example, the bigger the hole diameter, the more difficult it is proper placement and achieve plug stability or avoid sinking for off-bottom plugs. The risk of higher in-pipe contamination for deeper plugs, and finally, the nature and density of the wellbore fluid (high density, OBM, or WBM) worsening the effects of contamination or low density like completion fluids and brines becoming an issue to avoid sinking or slurry acceleration in the high salinity environment.

The good thing is that failure will only be predominantly affected by one variable, it would be either hole size, depth, or wellbore fluid. Understanding this is important to identify where to address design and prevention efforts. Remember, getting the cement plug right the first time.

In all my previous posts, however, I have not spoken about the use of tools. I have mentioned mechanical separators (more useful for plugs deeper than 3000m), but never actually really talked about placement aids, like the plug placement tool or the cement support tool.

The Cement Support Tool by Perigon

Coming up, I will be dedicating individual posts to these two tools in particular (Part 2 and Part 3). Here I prefer, rather than talk about my own experience with these, to reach out to the best companies around providing these services for more information and a description of their experience. However, you will have the chance to comment, support, or challenge the content in these future posts with your own knowledge. I am pretty much looking forward to this discussion.

Cheers

L. Diaz

Related posts:

  1. Is a base necessary for your Cement Plug? – Part 2
  2. Workover Cementing Techniques 2: Squeeze Cementing
  3. Cement, Spacer, all there. But where’s the wiper plug?
  4. Horizontal or highly deviated well section abandonment?

Filed Under: Plug Cementing Tagged With: cement plugs, CST, guidelines, PPT

Article Posted By:

Lenin Diaz is an oil industry specialist with 26 years of technical and operational expertise in fluids, cementing, water control and shut-off. A distinguished track record spanning BP, Schlumberger, and NAPESCO. Lenin lives in Tenerife, Spain and is the creator of this website. Read More…

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Ali Amer says

    September 17, 2020 at 6:52 pm

    It is match better for horizontal wells to spot small cement plug as a hard base and tag it before spot the cement plug insteadoff using DHT.
    Also using diverter perforated sub with closed end to breake the fluids on the end of tbg or DP reduce the contamination.

    Reply
    • Lenin Diaz says

      September 18, 2020 at 1:55 pm

      Thanks Ali for sharing your experience.
      Both of the practices you mention are legit and can provide solution in the applicable cases
      Cheers
      L. Diaz

      Reply
  2. Pushkaraj Altekar says

    September 23, 2020 at 11:38 am

    Lenin its nice and one of the sensitive issue aa far as Drilling Engineering is concerned. With my experince few of the following points / comments I would like ro mention.
    1. In case of KOP or any cement plug with partial return scenarios, it is always essential to have solid base like BP or strong high viscous pill to place a strong cement plug, but in many cases where the strong base is not able to provide the cement plug sagging or interface contamination may takes place which leads to not to having desire TOC. My suggestion in this regard a. Keep the viscosity of the pill min up to 150 ppb or more and b. Keep the plug under pressure after placement (500 to 600psi) depends upon well condition in order to get good compaction, helps to avoid contamination severity and probability of getting hard desired TOC in first attempt.

    2. In case of severe or complete loss condition, its very difficult to give assurance for first attempt success but with proper well data, actual formation data and with proper chemical composition and technique you may go close to perfection in first attempt.

    Reply
    • Lenin Diaz says

      September 24, 2020 at 11:22 am

      Hi @Pushkaraj Altekar, thanks for your excellent recommedations very applicable.
      Perhaps, just to mention from my experience, KOP meeting two objectives, cure losses and support for side-track, is sometimes a bit ambitious. In deep wells this a big concern due to the long trip times (POOH and RIH) or even worst in case of very hard formation.

      Reply
  3. Muthanna says

    September 24, 2020 at 10:42 am

    Hi Lenin,

    Thanks for this interesting article, indeed it is very important to achieve a successful cement plug from first attempt to save rig time and to reduce the consumption of cement materials. I have few points for discussion here;

    1- We always need to remember that cement plug recipe will be different for mud losses treatment from abandonment purpose. In mud losses scenario we will design the plug to be easily drilled to avoid sidetracking the well and restart the losses problem from zero. While in abandonment or sidetrack I will design the plug with enough hardness to achieve efficient isolation or sidetrack the well.

    2- During my career I saw many cementers rely on densimeter when pumping the cement slurry, in my opinion we always need to confirm the densimeter accuracy by measuring the slurry density using the pressurized mud balance, at least 3 times during pumping or every 5-10 minutes depend on estimated job time.

    3- It will be appreciated if you explain your thoughts whether you prefer to position the OEDP at top, in the middle or at bottom of the loss zone to spot the plug? Personally I prefer from top in case of complete/sever losses, and from bottom or in the middle of the zone in case of partial mud losses.

    4- Also for cement plugs with lengths of more than 250 m mostly for abandonment we can do it as back to back plug (split the plug to two plugs), we pump the first plug and WOC then we go and tag first plug to pump the second one. Let me know if you advise a different technique.

    Regards

    Reply
    • Lenin Diaz says

      September 24, 2020 at 11:26 am

      Dear Methane, only for this comments and evidence of experience, I can see you had a very nice career. I know, I was a witness for some time. Please be sure to extend all this knowledge to younger engineers and as usual if I can be of any help please do not hesitate to contact me
      All the best my friend

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Trango DEPM is a team of Oil&Gas professionals with broad experience in the O&G industry. Working on onshore and offshore projects around the world, including most vivid and challenging areas as Saudi Arabia, US Marcellus shale and North Sea, but also small on small projects, requiring individual approach, we are well equipped to help you plan, budget, implement and execute your drilling project successfully. We also cooperate with number of other professionals with experience in such areas as drilling, geology, geophysics, procurement or logistics. This allows us to fully run your project or just support you in desired areas of expertise, depends on you needs.

How I survived the 2016 Downturn and the current difficult times?

Find the content you need

Archives

24 Page Free Primary Cementing Guide

Click this image to take a look. It is comprehensive and easy to follow too!

In 2016, I launched Better Cementing for All. Now, I want to keep it alive.

For more than 26 years, I have worked in oil well cementing, offering my services to some of the largest oil corporations in the world and committing myself to excellence. I have mastered my role, and in doing so, I have accrued a skill set that is extremely valuable to my fellow professionals. Eager to do whatever I can to help them, I have owned and operated Better Cementing for All since 2016.
Let me tell you what Better Cementing for All does and what it means. A resource for all oil industry professionals and for cementers both established and prospective, this is a non-profit resource that I established in order to do nothing but serve and make an impact on people who are looking to build careers for themselves in cementing.
From primary cementing to remedial cementing to plug cementing to post-job results, I do it all, and I am comfortable answering in-depth questions about each and every one of these topics. I also offer tools and tips for jobseekers, general self-development advice, and guidance for equipment choices. TO put it simply, this is the go-to spot for anyone who wants to know anything about oil well cementing.
The problem, however, is that covid-19 has made the structure of the website seem untenable. I am trying to juggle the work that I do and my non-profit initiatives and finding it all unhealthy and unsustainable. I want to keep Better Cementing for All up and running, but to do that, I need your help.


My NEW introductory VIDEO

Recent Posts

Max Out Your Cement Coverage

If we consider the main variables to ensure proper mud in hole replacement with cement: stand-off, … [Read More...] about Max Out Your Cement Coverage

Cementing Flowchart

In recent weeks, I received some reader requests to include cement job processes or procedures as … [Read More...] about Cementing Flowchart

Cementing. Challenges across permeable zones

This article will provide you with some actionable suggestions for cementing across permeable zones. … [Read More...] about Cementing. Challenges across permeable zones

Forensic Cementing

Forensic is a term usually associated with crimes. Criminal forensics is the use of science to … [Read More...] about Forensic Cementing

Cement Slurry design Basics

First, here is a handy table to simplify the process of cement slurry design: Additive … [Read More...] about Cement Slurry design Basics

well cementing pre-job cement challenge question

Remedial Cementing with Coiled Tubing (animation)

Though I am far from being an animation expert, during my training courses I have always wanted to … [Read More...] about Remedial Cementing with Coiled Tubing (animation)

Need urgent help?

WhatsApp me at this number: +34 657 07 01 78

Footer

Recent activity

Visit our latest posts and help others by adding a comment.

Make your contribution and help keep Better Cementing for All alive!

Now more than ever, we are facing a loss of expertise in our industry, and Better Cementing for All is a unifying force, featuring interactions among industry professionals, knowledge sharing through posts, and other valuable pieces of content that we need to preserve.

Recent Comments

  • Merit on Cementing Equipment from Serva SJS Limited
  • Lenin Diaz on Cementing Equipment from Serva SJS Limited
  • Lenin Diaz on All you need to know about Bentonite in Cement Slurries
  • Lenin Diaz on Cementing Equipment from Serva SJS Limited
  • Lenin Diaz on Cementing Equipment from Serva SJS Limited
  • Lenin Diaz on Suicide Squeeze Cementing: risky but valid
  • Samuel Bekele Bedjiga on All you need to know about Bentonite in Cement Slurries

Recent Posts

  • Max Out Your Cement Coverage
  • Cementing Flowchart
  • Cementing. Challenges across permeable zones
  • Forensic Cementing
  • Cement Slurry design Basics
  • Remedial Cementing with Coiled Tubing (animation)
  • Plug and Abandonment Webinar (Español)
  • Webinar series (II). Quality Assurance in Cementing Operations (Spanish)
  • Webinar series (I). Log interpretation (Spanish)

Submit your email

&middot Better Well Cementing For All is owned by L. Diaz © 2023 &middot TOS & Privacy Policy &middot Web Design &middot