• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Primary Cementing
  • Remedial Cementing
  • Plug Cementing
  • Job Execution
  • Post-job results interpretation
  • Equipment
  • Laboratory
  • Mission
  • About
  • Contact and Questions?
  • My Cementing Challenges

Better Well Cementing for ALL

The Leading Online Support Hub for Better Oil Well Cementing.

Mixing Energy or Shear Rate? The effect on Cement Slurry?

November 13, 2017 By Lenin Diaz 2 Comments

Mixing Energy or Shear Rate? The effect on Cement Slurry?

Back in 2016, I posted an article on laboratory testing for cement slurries. In this article, I briefly referred to the changes in the preparation of the slurry in the laboratory, to account for the additional mixing energy typical in small slurry volume jobs using a batch-mixer. (Like in coiled tubing/CT operations).

A typical use for additional blending time

It is common in CT service companies to increase the time in the blender at 12,000 rpm. The purpose is to ‘simulate’ the additional mixing energy created, not only inside the batch-mixer but also through the CT when compared with the mixing energy derived from the standard API procedure. This knowledge has widely known for the last two decades.

Recently I found an article published in 1996, with some interesting conclusions about the effect of mixing energy on slurry properties. The article, in fact, concludes that mixing energy is not as important as shear rate.

Below are some relevant findings in this study:

  • At equal mixing energies, direct comparisons between the different devices (laboratory blender or field equipment) never led to matching results. In all cases, the differences among mixing devices were much more pronounced than the differences among various levels of mixing energy.
  • As the shear rate increases, the yield point declines dramatically at the lower shear rates and then tends to increase.
  • Shear rate is far more important than mixing energy in controlling slurry properties.

Here there is some good and bad news for CT engineers. The most important is that even if total mixing energy is higher when using the batch-mixer, the rate at which shear is applied is lower than lab equipment. This could lead to differences, the most important being rheology, a critical factor CT cementing.

Recent experience

Recently, I experienced the difference between laboratory and field equipment for a small cement slurry volume. In this case, the ‘standard’ additional mixing energy calculation was done and applied in the laboratory slurry preparation. All test protocols were followed for both the pilot testing and testing using field mix water. All slurry properties were in range for CT cementing and as intended.

However, during field mixing the slurry changed dramatically deviating from the expected behavior seen in the lab. Specifically, the slurry displayed high viscosity and gel strength development, which eventually caused the job to be aborted. Later during a yard test, again the slurry showed the similar behavior that was completely different from the performance in the laboratory.

An older personal example

Here is an older example, this one from my earlier days. The effect of mixing energy was investigated prior to a small volume cementing operation (cement squeeze) a using batch-mixer. We saw the following results.

In this case, we simulated the additional mixing energy with an extended time at 12,000 rpm. This caused an increase in Yield Point, Gel development, fluid loss and a decreased in thickening time. The cement slurry needed to be redesigned to counteract this effect and keep the properties in range to achieve the operational conditions and objectives.

As the article concludes:

“The cement mixing process is not completely understood. The various cement types and a large number of additives contribute significantly to the complexity”.

Reproducing mixing energy in the laboratory, using standard formulas, is definitely more practical and easy to implement. But, if the shear rate is more relevant to the final properties, the risk of experiencing unwanted cement slurry behavior in the field remains.

Please take a look at the article and share your opinion or experiences

Looking forward to your feedback

 

Cheers

L. Diaz

Related posts:

  1. Cement gelation: Come on! move it! push it! … Too late, it’s gelled up! …
  2. Workover Cementing Techniques 2: Squeeze Cementing
  3. Cement Slurry Laboratory Testing
  4. Misconceptions About Cementing

Filed Under: Laboratory, Remedial Cementing Tagged With: cement squeeze, CT, mixing energy, shear rate

Article Posted By:

Lenin Diaz is an oil industry specialist with 26 years of technical and operational expertise in fluids, cementing, water control and shut-off. A distinguished track record spanning BP, Schlumberger, and NAPESCO. Lenin lives in Tenerife, Spain and is the creator of this website. Read More…

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Samer says

    September 2, 2019 at 6:59 am

    Assuming that you don’t have a mixer in the lab that could reach 12000 RPM (not even close to 4000 RPM), is there any possible way to mix your cement slurries in your lab with a mixer with only 2000 RPM? if yes, what would be the best modified method to give as close as possible results to the standard API procedure?

    your feedback is highly appreciated

    Thanks and regards

    Reply
    • Lenin Diaz says

      September 2, 2019 at 7:28 pm

      Samer, let me do the calculation. If possible, after several minutes, I would think
      Will reply with more info …
      Bye for now
      L. Diaz

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Trango DEPM is a team of Oil&Gas professionals with broad experience in the O&G industry. Working on onshore and offshore projects around the world, including most vivid and challenging areas as Saudi Arabia, US Marcellus shale and North Sea, but also small on small projects, requiring individual approach, we are well equipped to help you plan, budget, implement and execute your drilling project successfully. We also cooperate with number of other professionals with experience in such areas as drilling, geology, geophysics, procurement or logistics. This allows us to fully run your project or just support you in desired areas of expertise, depends on you needs.

How I survived the 2016 Downturn and the current difficult times?

Find the content you need

Archives

24 Page Free Primary Cementing Guide

Click this image to take a look. It is comprehensive and easy to follow too!

In 2016, I launched Better Cementing for All. Now, I want to keep it alive.

For more than 26 years, I have worked in oil well cementing, offering my services to some of the largest oil corporations in the world and committing myself to excellence. I have mastered my role, and in doing so, I have accrued a skill set that is extremely valuable to my fellow professionals. Eager to do whatever I can to help them, I have owned and operated Better Cementing for All since 2016.
Let me tell you what Better Cementing for All does and what it means. A resource for all oil industry professionals and for cementers both established and prospective, this is a non-profit resource that I established in order to do nothing but serve and make an impact on people who are looking to build careers for themselves in cementing.
From primary cementing to remedial cementing to plug cementing to post-job results, I do it all, and I am comfortable answering in-depth questions about each and every one of these topics. I also offer tools and tips for jobseekers, general self-development advice, and guidance for equipment choices. TO put it simply, this is the go-to spot for anyone who wants to know anything about oil well cementing.
The problem, however, is that covid-19 has made the structure of the website seem untenable. I am trying to juggle the work that I do and my non-profit initiatives and finding it all unhealthy and unsustainable. I want to keep Better Cementing for All up and running, but to do that, I need your help.


My NEW introductory VIDEO

Recent Posts

Max Out Your Cement Coverage

If we consider the main variables to ensure proper mud in hole replacement with cement: stand-off, … [Read More...] about Max Out Your Cement Coverage

Cementing Flowchart

In recent weeks, I received some reader requests to include cement job processes or procedures as … [Read More...] about Cementing Flowchart

Cementing. Challenges across permeable zones

This article will provide you with some actionable suggestions for cementing across permeable zones. … [Read More...] about Cementing. Challenges across permeable zones

Forensic Cementing

Forensic is a term usually associated with crimes. Criminal forensics is the use of science to … [Read More...] about Forensic Cementing

Cement Slurry design Basics

First, here is a handy table to simplify the process of cement slurry design: Additive … [Read More...] about Cement Slurry design Basics

well cementing pre-job cement challenge question

Remedial Cementing with Coiled Tubing (animation)

Though I am far from being an animation expert, during my training courses I have always wanted to … [Read More...] about Remedial Cementing with Coiled Tubing (animation)

Need urgent help?

WhatsApp me at this number: +34 657 07 01 78

Footer

Recent activity

Visit our latest posts and help others by adding a comment.

Make your contribution and help keep Better Cementing for All alive!

Now more than ever, we are facing a loss of expertise in our industry, and Better Cementing for All is a unifying force, featuring interactions among industry professionals, knowledge sharing through posts, and other valuable pieces of content that we need to preserve.

Recent Comments

  • Merit on Cementing Equipment from Serva SJS Limited
  • Lenin Diaz on Cementing Equipment from Serva SJS Limited
  • Lenin Diaz on All you need to know about Bentonite in Cement Slurries
  • Lenin Diaz on Cementing Equipment from Serva SJS Limited
  • Lenin Diaz on Cementing Equipment from Serva SJS Limited
  • Lenin Diaz on Suicide Squeeze Cementing: risky but valid
  • Samuel Bekele Bedjiga on All you need to know about Bentonite in Cement Slurries

Recent Posts

  • Max Out Your Cement Coverage
  • Cementing Flowchart
  • Cementing. Challenges across permeable zones
  • Forensic Cementing
  • Cement Slurry design Basics
  • Remedial Cementing with Coiled Tubing (animation)
  • Plug and Abandonment Webinar (Español)
  • Webinar series (II). Quality Assurance in Cementing Operations (Spanish)
  • Webinar series (I). Log interpretation (Spanish)

Submit your email

&middot Better Well Cementing For All is owned by L. Diaz © 2023 &middot TOS & Privacy Policy &middot Web Design &middot